Part 12 of 13 · Redevelopment Guide for Housing Societies (Pune & PCMC)

By Advocate Ketan Palshikar | Last updated: 15 November 2026 | Based on Government Order No. SGHYO-2026/CR-108/14-S dated 30 September 2026

Introduction

One of the most sensitive aspects of cooperative housing society redevelopment is the position of members who do not support the proposed redevelopment, members who remain absent from important meetings and members who reside outside India.

In many housing societies, some members may oppose redevelopment because they are dissatisfied with the proposed additional carpet area, corpus, transit rent, developer selection, construction specifications or the overall commercial arrangement.

Some members may be unable to attend meetings because of employment, illness, age, disability or residence outside India. Others may simply choose not to participate.

These situations frequently raise practical questions:

  • Can a minority of members prevent the society from undertaking redevelopment?
  • Can the society proceed if some members vote against the proposal?
  • Are the views of absent members considered?
  • Can an NRI member participate through video conferencing?
  • Can an NRI member appoint a representative to attend the redevelopment meeting?
  • Is written consent required from every member?
  • Can a member refuse to vacate the existing premises?
  • What happens when a member does not sign the Permanent Alternate Accommodation Agreement (PAAA)?

The Maharashtra Government Order dated 30 September 2026 contains specific procedural provisions concerning quorum, voting, remote participation, written consent and developer selection.

This article examines these provisions and explains the legal and practical considerations concerning dissenting, absent and NRI members.

1. Understanding the Different Categories of Members

For redevelopment-related decision-making, it is useful to distinguish between the following categories.

A. Members supporting redevelopment

These are members who vote in favour of the redevelopment proposal at the relevant General Body Meeting.

The Government Order requires written consent from members who voted in favour of the preliminary redevelopment resolution before the society proceeds with further action.

B. Dissenting members

These are members who participate in the meeting but vote against the redevelopment proposal or developer selection.

Their objections may concern the project itself, the developer, the commercial terms or the proposed contractual arrangements.

C. Absent members

These are members who do not attend the relevant meeting, either physically or through an eligible remote participation arrangement.

The Government Order expressly addresses the treatment of absent members’ views and consents.

D. NRI and overseas members

These are members who reside outside India and may be unable to attend meetings physically.

The 2026 Government Order specifically permits eligible members residing abroad to participate through remote systems or video conferencing in the circumstances and subject to the conditions specified in the order.

An NRI member should not be treated as automatically absent merely because the member resides outside India.

2. The Preliminary Decision to Undertake Redevelopment

The first important decision is whether the society should undertake redevelopment at all.

The 30 September 2026 Government Order provides a specific procedure for convening the Special General Body Meeting (SGM) and obtaining the preliminary approval.

A. Quorum

The quorum for the redevelopment SGM is two-thirds of the society’s total membership.

For example:

If a society has 100 members:

  • Total membership: 100.
  • Required quorum: 2/3.
  • Minimum quorum: 67 members, after rounding upwards.

If the required quorum is not present, the meeting must be adjourned and reconvened within the prescribed period, after giving seven days’ notice.

If the quorum is again not achieved at the reconvened meeting, the meeting is to be cancelled on the basis that members are not interested in redevelopment. The same subject cannot be brought before the SGM for approval again for three months.

B. Approval by members

The preliminary redevelopment decision must be approved by a majority of not less than 51% of the society’s total membership.

The Government Order explains that the required approval is calculated with reference to the total membership, not merely the members attending the meeting.

For a society with 100 members, at least 51 members must approve the preliminary redevelopment proposal.

C. Physical attendance and video conferencing

The Government Order permits members who are abroad, seriously ill, disabled or unable to attend physically due to unavoidable circumstances to participate through remote systems or video conferencing.

Such participation is recognised for:

  • The two-thirds quorum; and
  • The 51% approval requirement.

However, the order expressly requires that at least 51% of the society’s total membership must be physically present at the meeting.

This condition is important and should not be overlooked.

Illustration:

A society has 100 members.

  • Required quorum: 67.
  • Minimum physical attendance: 51.
  • Eligible VC participants may be counted towards the quorum and approval requirement.
  • At least 51 members must nevertheless be physically present.

The society should maintain an accurate attendance record distinguishing physical attendance from remote participation.

3. Are the Views of Absent Members Considered?

The 2026 Government Order expressly provides that the views of absent members are not to be considered for the preliminary redevelopment decision.

It specifically states that written, oral or other forms of approval, opinion or consent from members who are absent from the meeting will not be considered in the meeting proceedings.

This has an important practical consequence.

A member who does not attend the meeting cannot ordinarily rely on a separate letter or informal communication as a substitute for participation in the prescribed meeting process.

For example:

  • A member sends an email stating that redevelopment is acceptable.
  • The member does not attend physically or through an eligible VC arrangement.
  • The member’s email is not treated as attendance or a vote in the SGM.

Similarly, a member who sends a written objection but remains absent does not thereby become a participant in the voting process.

The society should record the attendance and voting accurately and should not include absent members’ opinions as votes.

Important distinction

This provision concerns the treatment of absent members’ views in the prescribed SGM decision-making process.

It should not be interpreted as a general statement that an absent member loses all legal rights concerning the property, contractual entitlement or possession.

Those rights must be examined separately under the applicable law and the relevant documents.

4. Written Consent After the Preliminary Redevelopment Resolution

Passing the preliminary redevelopment resolution is not the end of the approval process.

The 2026 Government Order provides that after the redevelopment proposal is approved by the required majority, the managing committee must obtain written consent from the members who voted in favour of the resolution before proceeding with further redevelopment-related action.

This requirement should be distinguished from the voting itself.

Voting and written consent are separate steps

The society should maintain:

  1. The attendance record.
  2. The voting record.
  3. The names of members who voted in favour.
  4. The written consent letters of those members.

The written consent should be properly preserved in the society’s records.

Is written consent required from every member?

The provision specifically refers to members who voted in favour of the redevelopment resolution.

It does not state that every member, including those who voted against the resolution or remained absent, must provide written consent for the preliminary decision to be treated as approved.

However, this does not mean that all individual contractual formalities can be bypassed later.

The individual PAAA and other documentation requirements must be considered separately.

5. Rights of Dissenting Members

A dissenting member is a member who participates in the meeting but does not support the redevelopment proposal.

The 2026 Government Order establishes a collective decision-making process based on the prescribed quorum and majority requirements.

Accordingly, the mere fact that some members vote against redevelopment does not automatically mean that the proposal fails.

For example:

A society has 100 members.

At the preliminary redevelopment SGM:

  • 70 members attend physically.
  • 20 vote against redevelopment.
  • 50 vote in favour.

The required approval is at least 51 members out of the total membership of 100.

Since only 50 members have voted in favour, the required approval has not been achieved.

Now consider another situation:

  • 70 members attend physically.
  • 15 vote against redevelopment.
  • 55 vote in favour.

The proposal satisfies the numerical requirement of at least 51% of the total membership, assuming the other procedural requirements have been met.

The dissenting votes remain part of the meeting record, but they do not automatically defeat a proposal that has obtained the prescribed approval.

Does a dissenting member have a veto?

The Government Order does not provide an individual veto merely because a member disagrees with the redevelopment decision.

The decision is made through the prescribed collective approval mechanism.

However, this does not mean that the majority can disregard the legal rights of individual members.

The society and developer must still comply with:

  • The applicable statutory provisions.
  • The approved redevelopment procedure.
  • The registered Development Agreement.
  • The member’s individual PAAA.
  • The member’s existing legal rights.
  • The applicable requirements concerning possession and vacation.

A majority resolution cannot be treated as unrestricted authority to deprive a member of legally protected rights.

6. Can Dissenting Members Raise Objections During the Meeting?

Yes.

The 2026 Government Order provides that members who wish to express their views or raise objections during the developer-selection SGM must be given an opportunity to do so.

The meeting proceedings should therefore allow members to raise relevant concerns.

The society should ensure that material objections and responses are appropriately recorded in the minutes.

Examples of issues that members may raise include:

  • Inadequate additional carpet area.
  • Insufficient transit rent.
  • Unacceptable corpus.
  • Inadequate bank guarantee.
  • Doubts concerning the developer’s financial capacity.
  • Incomplete construction specifications.
  • Unclear project timeline.
  • Inadequate parking arrangements.
  • Concerns regarding the Development Agreement.
  • Inadequate security against delay or default.

Recording objections

The society should maintain a clear record of:

  • The name of the member raising the objection.
  • The subject of the objection.
  • The relevant clarification or response.
  • Any undertaking or assurance given.
  • Whether the issue was resolved or remains outstanding.

A transparent record helps reduce future disputes concerning the manner in which the decision was taken.

7. Can a Member Challenge the Redevelopment Decision?

A member may raise a legal challenge if there is a genuine and legally sustainable ground.

However, mere disagreement with the majority decision should be distinguished from an allegation of illegality, procedural violation, fraud or breach of contractual or statutory rights.

Possible grounds requiring legal examination may include:

  • Failure to satisfy the prescribed quorum.
  • Incorrect calculation of the required majority.
  • Defective notice or improper service.
  • Failure to follow the prescribed procedure.
  • Suppression of material information.
  • Fraud or collusion.
  • Undisclosed conflict of interest.
  • Material deviation from the approved terms.
  • Unlawful deprivation of possession or contractual entitlement.
  • Non-compliance with applicable statutory requirements.

The appropriate forum and remedy depend on the nature of the dispute and the applicable legislation.

The 2026 Government Order itself requires the redevelopment contract to contain a provision for approaching the competent court or authority under the prevailing laws in the event of a dispute.

A member should therefore obtain legal advice based on the actual facts, documents and nature of the grievance.

8. Rights of NRI and Overseas Members

A member residing outside India may face practical difficulties in attending redevelopment meetings.

The 2026 Government Order specifically recognises this situation.

It permits members residing abroad, along with seriously ill, disabled and other members unable to attend physically due to unavoidable circumstances, to participate through remote systems or video conferencing.

Their remote attendance is recognised for quorum and the applicable voting requirements, subject to the physical attendance condition.

Important points for NRI members

An overseas member should:

  1. Keep the society informed of the current overseas address and contact details.
  2. Ensure that the society has a valid email address.
  3. Respond to redevelopment meeting notices.
  4. Request remote participation where eligible.
  5. Confirm the VC joining procedure in advance.
  6. Keep copies of notices and meeting communications.
  7. Ensure that the member’s attendance and vote are properly recorded.

Can an NRI member participate in the preliminary redevelopment SGM through VC?

Yes, subject to the conditions in the Government Order.

The member must fall within the eligible category and participate through the prescribed remote arrangement.

The society should also ensure that the minimum 51% physical attendance requirement is satisfied.

9. Can an NRI Member Appoint a Representative to Attend the Developer-Selection SGM?

This is a particularly important distinction.

The 2026 Government Order provides that only authorised members themselves may attend the developer-selection SGM.

It expressly states that a member cannot send a representative.

The member must carry a valid identity document, and the authorised officer is required to verify the member’s identity using the membership register, share certificate and valid identity document before the meeting begins.

Therefore, an NRI member should not assume that a relative, attorney holder or other representative can attend the developer-selection SGM and exercise the member’s voting rights.

The order separately permits eligible overseas members to participate through VC.

Accordingly, an NRI member who cannot attend physically should examine the possibility of eligible remote participation rather than relying on a representative.

What about a Power of Attorney?

A Power of Attorney may be relevant for specific documentation and other legally permissible acts.

However, it should not be assumed that a Power of Attorney automatically authorises the holder to attend and vote at the developer-selection SGM as a representative.

The specific meeting procedure under the Government Order must be followed.

10. Remote Participation in the Developer-Selection SGM

The developer-selection SGM has its own detailed procedure.

The 2026 Government Order provides that eligible members who are abroad, seriously ill, disabled or unable to attend physically due to unavoidable circumstances may participate through VC or remote systems.

Their attendance is recognised for:

  • The two-thirds quorum.
  • The developer-selection voting requirement.

However, at least 51% of the total membership must be physically present.

The authorised officer must verify attendance and quorum.

The society is required to arrange the necessary VC service provider.

Remote voting

The order also provides for arrangements for remote participants if secret ballot voting is required.

Where secret ballot is requested in writing by at least one-fifth of the total membership, the authorised officer must make the necessary arrangements, including for eligible VC participants.

The society should therefore ensure that the technical arrangement permits proper identification, participation and recording of votes.

11. Voting at the Developer-Selection SGM

The developer-selection SGM is an important stage because the society selects the developer from the tenders received.

The 2026 Government Order provides that:

  • The meeting must be held in the presence of the Registrar’s authorised officer.
  • The quorum is two-thirds of the total membership.
  • Eligible overseas and other specified members may participate through VC.
  • At least 51% of the total membership must be physically present.
  • Only actual members may attend; representatives are not permitted.
  • Members must carry valid identity documents.
  • The authorised officer must verify identity.
  • The meeting must be video-recorded.

Voting procedure

The developer may be selected by a show of hands.

However, if at least one-fifth of the total membership submits a written request for secret ballot, the authorised officer must arrange secret ballot voting.

The selection requires approval of not less than 51% of the total membership through the prescribed voting process.

Eligible VC participants are counted for the voting requirement, subject to the mandatory physical attendance condition.

The society should not confuse the 51% approval requirement with a simple majority of those who happen to attend.

12. Does the Developer-Selection SGM Also Require Written Consent?

Yes.

The 2026 Government Order requires written approval or consent from members representing at least 51% of the total membership for appointment of the selected developer.

The society should preserve the written consent records along with:

  • Attendance sheet.
  • Voting record.
  • SGM minutes.
  • Developer’s consent.
  • Video recording.
  • Authorised officer’s report.

The society must submit the prescribed documents to the Registrar within 14 days after the meeting.

The authorised officer must also submit the meeting report and video recording to the Registrar’s office.

13. Can an Absent Member’s Consent Be Used Later?

The answer depends on the specific stage of redevelopment and the relevant requirement.

The Government Order expressly states that absent members’ written, oral or other opinions are not considered in the preliminary redevelopment SGM decision.

It also prescribes specific written-consent requirements for members who voted in favour.

At the developer-selection stage, the order requires the prescribed voting and written approval process.

Therefore, a society should not treat an informal letter from an absent member as a substitute for attendance, voting or written consent where the Government Order prescribes a specific procedure.

The society should maintain separate records for:

  • Members physically present.
  • Eligible VC participants.
  • Members voting in favour.
  • Members voting against.
  • Members absent.
  • Written consent letters received.

14. Can a Dissenting Member Be Compelled to Vacate?

This question requires careful legal consideration.

The 2026 Government Order provides that members should vacate their existing premises only after all necessary legal approvals have been obtained and the individual PAAA has been registered.

It also states that the rights of persons in possession of their premises remain protected.

Therefore, a majority resolution should not be treated as an automatic substitute for the legal and contractual requirements governing vacation.

The following questions should be examined in each case:

  • Has the redevelopment proposal been approved through the prescribed process?
  • Has the developer been selected lawfully?
  • Has the Development Agreement been registered?
  • Have all necessary legal approvals been obtained?
  • Has the concerned member’s PAAA been executed and registered?
  • Have the agreed transit accommodation arrangements been made?
  • Are there any specific legal orders or disputes affecting possession?

A member’s refusal to vacate cannot be assessed merely by looking at the voting result.

The society and developer should obtain legal advice before taking steps affecting possession.

15. What If a Member Refuses to Sign the PAAA?

The PAAA is an individual agreement recording the member’s permanent alternate accommodation entitlement.

The 2026 Government Order requires registration of individual PAAA within three months after registration of the Development Agreement.

Where a member refuses to sign the PAAA, the society and developer should first identify the reason.

Possible reasons may include:

  • Incorrect carpet area.
  • Disagreement over premises identification.
  • Disagreement over transit rent.
  • Unrecorded financial benefits.
  • Changes from the approved entitlement.
  • Inadequate construction specifications.
  • Unacceptable contractual clauses.
  • Concern regarding the developer’s performance.
  • Other genuine legal or factual objections.

Recommended approach

  1. Obtain the member’s objections in writing.
  2. Compare the proposed PAAA with the registered Development Agreement.
  3. Verify the member’s entitlement schedule.
  4. Identify whether the objection is justified.
  5. Correct any genuine discrepancy.
  6. Obtain independent legal advice.
  7. Preserve all correspondence and communications.

The society should not assume that a member’s refusal to sign automatically extinguishes the member’s rights.

Equally, a member should not assume that withholding a signature automatically prevents the entire redevelopment project from proceeding.

The legal position depends on the contractual documents, statutory requirements and facts of the particular case.

16. Can the Society Proceed Despite Dissenting Members?

The 2026 Government Order provides a collective approval mechanism.

If the prescribed quorum, voting and consent requirements are fulfilled, the preliminary redevelopment decision and subsequent developer-selection process may proceed in accordance with the order.

However, the society must continue to respect individual members’ legal and contractual rights.

The distinction is between:

  • The collective decision to undertake redevelopment; and
  • The individual member’s rights concerning accommodation, contractual entitlement, possession and other legally protected interests.

These are connected but separate legal issues.

The society should not assume that a valid majority resolution automatically resolves every individual dispute.

17. Documents NRI and Overseas Members Should Keep Ready

Members residing abroad should maintain an organised set of property and society documents.

These may include:

  • Membership details.
  • Share certificate.
  • Existing flat or shop documents.
  • Registered purchase agreement or other title document.
  • Society correspondence.
  • PAN and other identity documents.
  • Current overseas address.
  • Updated email and contact details.
  • Copies of redevelopment notices.
  • PAAA and related documents.
  • Power of Attorney, where required for legally permissible documentation.

Where documents are executed outside India, the applicable requirements concerning notarisation, apostille, consular attestation, stamping and registration should be examined separately.

A Power of Attorney should be drafted for the specific purpose for which it is intended.

18. Practical Checklist for Managing Committees

The managing committee should ensure that the rights and participation of all members are handled transparently.

Before the preliminary redevelopment SGM

  • Verify the total membership.
  • Issue notice to all members as prescribed.
  • Maintain proof of service.
  • Identify members requesting VC participation.
  • Verify eligibility for remote participation.
  • Ensure the minimum physical attendance requirement.
  • Record attendance separately.
  • Calculate quorum correctly.
  • Record votes accurately.
  • Record members’ suggestions and objections.
  • Obtain written consent from members who voted in favour.

Before the developer-selection SGM

  • Obtain appointment of the Registrar’s authorised officer.
  • Issue the prescribed notice.
  • Circulate the comparative tender statement.
  • Arrange the required VC facility.
  • Verify the minimum physical attendance.
  • Verify the identity of attending members.
  • Do not permit representatives in place of members.
  • Provide an opportunity for objections.
  • Arrange voting in the prescribed manner.
  • Record written approval and consent.
  • Video-record the meeting.
  • Submit the prescribed records to the Registrar within 14 days.

During individual PAAA execution

  • Verify member-wise entitlement.
  • Confirm carpet area.
  • Record agreed financial benefits.
  • Confirm transit accommodation arrangements.
  • Address genuine objections.
  • Register the PAAA.
  • Maintain registration records.

19. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. Can a minority of members stop redevelopment by voting against it?

Not merely because they form a minority. The Government Order prescribes collective approval requirements. If the required quorum and majority are achieved, dissenting votes do not automatically defeat the proposal. However, individual legal rights remain protected.

Q2. Is the approval of 51% of members attending the meeting sufficient?

No. The preliminary redevelopment decision requires approval of at least 51% of the society’s total membership. The developer-selection process also contains a 51% total-membership approval requirement.

Q3. Can an NRI member attend the redevelopment SGM through video conferencing?

Yes. The Government Order permits eligible members residing abroad to participate through VC or remote systems, subject to its conditions. The minimum physical attendance requirement must also be satisfied.

Q4. Can an NRI member appoint a relative to vote on their behalf at the developer-selection SGM?

The developer-selection procedure expressly states that representatives cannot attend in place of members. Eligible overseas members may instead participate through VC.

Q5. Are absent members’ written objections considered in the preliminary SGM?

The Government Order expressly states that written, oral or other opinions or approvals of absent members are not considered in that meeting’s proceedings.

Q6. Is written consent required from every member after the preliminary redevelopment resolution?

The order requires written consent from members who voted in favour of the preliminary redevelopment resolution. It does not prescribe written consent from every member at that particular stage.

Q7. Can a dissenting member challenge the redevelopment process?

A member may pursue an appropriate legal remedy if there is a sustainable ground such as procedural illegality, fraud, breach of statutory requirements or infringement of legal rights. Mere disagreement with the majority decision should be distinguished from a legally actionable grievance.

Q8. Can a dissenting member be required to vacate immediately after the majority resolution?

No. The Government Order requires all necessary legal approvals and registration of the individual PAAA before members vacate their premises.

Q9. What happens if a member refuses to sign the PAAA?

The society and developer should identify and examine the reasons for refusal. A refusal does not automatically extinguish the member’s rights, nor does it automatically determine whether the redevelopment can proceed. The issue requires examination of the relevant documents and applicable law.

Q10. Can the society ignore an NRI member because the member does not attend meetings?

No. The society should serve notices in accordance with the prescribed procedure and provide the eligible remote participation facility where the Government Order permits it.

Conclusion

The rights of dissenting, absent and NRI members must be understood in the context of the collective decision-making framework prescribed for housing society redevelopment.

The 30 September 2026 Government Order provides specific requirements concerning quorum, minimum approval, physical attendance, video conferencing, written consent and developer-selection voting.

It recognises the practical difficulties faced by overseas and other eligible members while also maintaining a minimum physical attendance requirement.

At the same time, the collective approval of redevelopment should not be confused with unrestricted authority over individual members’ rights.

The society must continue to comply with the requirements concerning registered PAAA, legal approvals, accommodation entitlements and protection of possession.

For managing committees, the key objective should be transparent decision-making and accurate documentation. For individual members, particularly dissenting and overseas members, the important step is to participate through the prescribed procedure, raise objections in writing and carefully examine the documents affecting their individual entitlements.

A properly documented redevelopment process can reduce unnecessary disputes while protecting both the collective interests of the society and the legal rights of its members.


Related Articles in This 13-Part Redevelopment Guide

  1. Part 1: Housing Society Redevelopment in Maharashtra: The Complete Step-by-Step Roadmap
  2. Part 2: 2019 vs 2026 Government Order: What Has Changed in Maharashtra Housing Society Redevelopment?
  3. Part 3: Before You Begin: Legal, Structural and Financial Checks Before Housing Society Redevelopment
  4. Part 4: Special General Body Meeting for Redevelopment: Notice, Quorum, Voting and Legal Requirements
  5. Part 5: Role of Architect and PMC in Housing Society Redevelopment
  6. Part 6: Tender Process for Housing Society Redevelopment: Rules, Transparency and Developer Offers
  7. Part 7: Developer Selection in Housing Society Redevelopment: Registrar’s Authorised Officer and Voting Procedure
  8. Part 8: Developer Due Diligence: How a Housing Society Should Verify a Redeveloper
  9. Part 9: Development Agreement and PAAA: Protecting Members’ Rights in Redevelopment
  10. Part 10: From Demolition to Possession: Construction, Approvals and Handover
  11. Part 11: Self-Redevelopment and Group Redevelopment in Maharashtra
  12. Part 12: Dissenting, Absent, Deceased and NRI Members in Housing Society Redevelopment
  13. Part 13: Housing Society Redevelopment FAQs, Legal Checklist and Glossary
  14. Download Maharashtra Government GR सगृयो-2026/प्र.क्र.108/14-स for Re-Development dated 30/09/2026

Legal Disclaimer: This article is intended for general legal information and educational purposes. The legal consequences of dissent, absence, refusal to execute a PAAA or refusal to vacate depend on the facts, applicable statutory provisions, registered documents and judicial decisions. The rights and remedies of individual members should be examined independently before any action affecting possession or contractual entitlement is taken.