Part 5 of 13 · Redevelopment Guide for Housing Societies (Pune & PCMC)

By Advocate Ketan Palshikar | Last updated: 15 November 2026 | Based on Government Order No. SGHYO-2026/CR-108/14-S dated 30 September 2026

1. Introduction

The appointment of an Architect or Project Management Consultant (PMC) is one of the most important stages in a housing society redevelopment project.

At this stage, the society must move beyond general discussions about redevelopment and obtain an objective, technically sound assessment of the redevelopment potential of its property.

The Architect / PMC is expected to examine the society’s land and building, assess the applicable development regulations, identify the potential development benefits, evaluate different redevelopment possibilities and prepare a realistic Project Report.

This report becomes the technical foundation for the society’s subsequent decisions, including preparation of tender conditions, invitation of offers from developers and comparison of competing redevelopment proposals.

A poorly prepared Project Report can result in unrealistic expectations, inadequate tender conditions, disputes with developers and financial or practical difficulties during implementation.

Therefore, the society should not treat the appointment of an Architect / PMC as a mere procedural formality. It should select a competent, experienced and independent professional who can protect the collective interests of the society and its members.

2. Legal Framework Under the 2026 Government Order

The procedure for appointing an Architect / PMC and obtaining the Project Report is primarily governed by Paragraphs 8, 9 and 10 of the Government Order dated 30 September 2026.

The relevant provisions establish the following sequence:

  1. The society must appoint the Architect / PMC within the prescribed period after the initial redevelopment decision.
  2. The appointment must be supported by a written agreement.
  3. The Architect / PMC must undertake a survey of the society’s building and land.
  4. The professional must examine conveyance-related information and the applicable development regulations.
  5. The available FSI and TDR potential must be assessed.
  6. A realistic Project Report must be prepared, considering the members’ requirements and the development possibilities.
  7. The Project Report must be submitted to the Managing Committee within two months from the date of appointment.
  8. The report must thereafter be considered by the Managing Committee, with an opportunity for members to submit suggestions and recommendations.

The 2026 Government Order requires the society to issue the appointment letter within 30 days of the relevant General Body Meeting and enter into a written agreement with the appointed Architect / PMC on the terms and conditions approved by the General Body.

The Project Report is required to be prepared within two months from the date of appointment.

These are prescribed procedural timelines and should be incorporated into the society’s redevelopment programme.

3. Who Should Be Appointed: Architect or PMC?

A housing society may appoint an Architect or a Project Management Consultant, depending on the nature and requirements of the proposed redevelopment.

Although the terms are sometimes used interchangeably, their professional functions may differ.

3.1 Architect

An Architect is primarily concerned with the architectural and planning aspects of the project.

The scope may include:

  • Studying the existing building and site conditions.
  • Assessing planning possibilities under applicable development regulations.
  • Preparing conceptual layouts and building configurations.
  • Evaluating residential and commercial development possibilities.
  • Examining open spaces, gardens, parking and circulation requirements.
  • Preparing architectural drawings and development concepts.
  • Assessing the feasibility of different planning options.

3.2 Project Management Consultant (PMC)

A PMC may provide a broader range of technical and project-management services.

Depending on the agreed scope, these may include:

  • Coordinating architectural, structural and engineering assessments.
  • Examining the technical feasibility of redevelopment.
  • Evaluating development proposals and project economics.
  • Preparing the Project Report.
  • Drafting technical specifications and tender conditions.
  • Scrutinising developers’ offers.
  • Preparing comparative statements.
  • Monitoring project progress and construction quality.
  • Coordinating with the society, developer, consultants and authorities.

3.3 Can the Society Appoint Both?

Yes. Depending on the project’s complexity, the society may appoint an Architect and a separate PMC, or appoint a professional organisation capable of providing both services.

However, the society should clearly define the respective responsibilities and avoid duplication or gaps in accountability.

The 2026 Government Order refers to an Architect / Project Management Consultant. The precise professional arrangement should be decided by the society in accordance with its project requirements and the approved scope of appointment.

4. Procedure for Appointment of Architect / PMC

The appointment process begins with the initial redevelopment decision taken by the General Body.

Under Paragraph 4 of the 2026 Government Order, the society is required to obtain quotations from at least three registered Architects / empanelled PMCs for preparation of the Project Report before the relevant Special General Body Meeting.

The members are required to select the professional through the prescribed process.

After the decision:

  1. The Managing Committee should record the appointment decision in its minutes.
  2. The appointment letter should be issued within 30 days.
  3. A written agreement should be executed between the society and the appointed professional.
  4. The agreement should incorporate the scope of work, professional fees, deliverables, timelines and other approved terms.

The society should preserve all quotations, comparative statements, meeting notices, minutes, appointment letters and the executed agreement in its redevelopment records.

5. Selection Criteria: How Should the Society Evaluate an Architect / PMC?

The society should not select an Architect / PMC solely on the basis of the lowest professional fee.

A redevelopment project involves substantial financial, technical and legal considerations. The professional appointed at this stage will influence the quality of the Project Report and the society’s subsequent tendering and developer-selection process.

The following factors should be considered.

5.1 Experience in Housing Society Redevelopment

The professional should have demonstrable experience in cooperative housing society redevelopment, preferably in projects involving similar land characteristics, building configurations and development constraints.

Experience in ordinary residential architecture alone may not necessarily establish expertise in redevelopment.

5.2 Knowledge of Applicable Development Regulations

The professional should understand the development regulations applicable to the particular property and planning authority.

For properties in Pune, the applicable framework may depend on whether the property falls within the jurisdiction of Pune Municipal Corporation, PMRDA or another competent planning authority.

The professional should also examine any applicable special regulations relating to MHADA, SRA, CIDCO, MMRDA or other authorities, where relevant.

5.3 Technical and Financial Evaluation Capability

The professional should be capable of evaluating different development scenarios and explaining their practical implications to members.

A good Project Report should not merely show the maximum possible construction potential. It should demonstrate what can realistically be planned and implemented.

5.4 Independence and Conflict of Interest

The Architect / PMC should act in the interest of the society and its members.

The society should obtain a written declaration regarding any existing professional, financial or commercial relationship with prospective developers, contractors or other persons participating in the project.

The professional should disclose any actual or potential conflict of interest.

5.5 Professional Credentials and References

The society should verify:

  • Relevant professional registration and qualifications.
  • Experience in redevelopment projects.
  • Details of completed or ongoing projects.
  • References from other cooperative housing societies.
  • Availability of qualified technical staff.
  • Professional indemnity insurance, where applicable.
  • Capacity to complete the assignment within the prescribed timeline.

6. Scope of Work of the Architect / PMC Under the 2026 Government Order

Paragraph 9 of the Government Order specifically identifies the initial responsibilities of the Architect / PMC.

These responsibilities should be reflected in the written appointment agreement.

6.1 Survey of the Society’s Building and Land

The professional must undertake a survey of the society’s existing building and land.

The exercise should establish the physical characteristics of the property, including:

  • Total land area and plot boundaries.
  • Existing building footprint.
  • Number of buildings and floors.
  • Existing flats and other premises.
  • Existing carpet areas, to the extent ascertainable.
  • Common areas and amenities.
  • Existing parking arrangements.
  • Internal access roads and open spaces.
  • Site constraints and physical obstructions.

The survey should be based on available property records and appropriate site measurements.

The society should ensure that discrepancies between the actual site conditions and available plans or property documents are identified and reported.

6.2 Examination of Conveyance Status

The Government Order specifically requires the Architect / PMC to obtain information concerning conveyance of the society’s land.

The professional should examine the available documents and identify whether the society has obtained:

  • Registered conveyance deed;
  • Deemed conveyance order and subsequent conveyance deed, where applicable;
  • Property ownership documents;
  • Property card or relevant revenue records;
  • Land measurement and survey documents;
  • Relevant lease documents, where the land is leasehold.

The Architect / PMC should identify conveyance-related issues that may affect redevelopment feasibility and bring them to the society’s attention.

However, the Architect / PMC’s examination does not replace an independent legal title investigation by an advocate experienced in property documentation.

The society should obtain appropriate legal advice regarding ownership, title defects, encumbrances, development rights, lease conditions and other legal issues.

6.3 Examination of Applicable Development Regulations

The Architect / PMC must consider the rules and regulations applicable to the ownership and location of the land.

Depending on the property, the relevant authority or regulatory framework may include:

  • Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC);
  • Pimpri-Chinchwad Municipal Corporation (PCMC);
  • Pune Metropolitan Region Development Authority (PMRDA);
  • Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority (MHADA);
  • Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA);
  • City and Industrial Development Corporation (CIDCO);
  • Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA), where applicable;
  • Other competent planning or development authorities.

The professional should identify the regulations applicable to the specific property rather than relying on general redevelopment assumptions.

For example, the development potential of a property situated within PMC limits may differ from that of a property governed by PMRDA or a special planning authority.

6.4 Assessment of Available FSI and TDR

One of the most important responsibilities is to assess the available Floor Space Index (FSI) and Transferable Development Rights (TDR).

The professional should examine:

  • Basic permissible FSI.
  • Additional FSI, if available.
  • Premium FSI, where applicable.
  • TDR potential and applicable loading restrictions.
  • Benefits available under the relevant redevelopment regulations.
  • Road width and access-related restrictions.
  • Reservation or designation affecting the land.
  • Setbacks, margins and open-space requirements.
  • Height restrictions and aviation-related limitations, where applicable.
  • Fire access and other mandatory planning requirements.
  • Any restrictions arising from the nature of land ownership or special authority regulations.

The Project Report should clearly explain the basis of the FSI and TDR calculations.

The society should not accept an unexplained statement that a particular percentage of additional FSI is available.

The professional should identify the applicable regulatory provisions and explain the assumptions used in arriving at the development potential.

Important: FSI and TDR are not uniform across Maharashtra. The permissible development potential must be determined with reference to the regulations applicable to the specific property and the relevant planning authority.

6.5 Preparation of a Realistic Project Report

The Government Order requires the Architect / PMC to prepare a realistic Project Report after considering the suggestions and recommendations of the members.

The report should address, among other things:

  • Residential area to be provided to existing members.
  • Commercial area, wherever applicable.
  • Open spaces.
  • Garden and recreational facilities.
  • Parking arrangements.
  • Building specifications.
  • Available development potential.
  • Different planning schemes and their respective benefits.

The Project Report should not be confined to a single development option.

Where different schemes are available under the applicable Development Control Regulations or Unified Development Control and Promotion Regulations (UDCPR), the Architect / PMC should prepare separate project reports for the different options and a comparative statement.

This is important because different planning options may produce different outcomes in terms of member entitlement, construction feasibility, parking, open spaces, project cost and commercial viability.

7. What Should a Comprehensive Project Report Contain?

Although the Government Order identifies the principal matters to be examined, the society should ensure that the report is sufficiently detailed to support informed decision-making.

The following structure may be adopted.

A. Property and Site Details

  • Name and registration details of the society.
  • Property address and location.
  • Survey number, CTS number, Gat number or other land identification.
  • Total land area.
  • Existing building details.
  • Existing sanctioned plans and available permissions.
  • Existing occupation and possession details.
  • Conveyance and land ownership status, based on available documents.

B. Existing Development Details

  • Number of existing flats and commercial units.
  • Existing carpet areas.
  • Common areas and amenities.
  • Existing parking facilities.
  • Building condition and available structural information.
  • Existing access and internal circulation.

C. Development Potential

  • Applicable planning authority.
  • Applicable development regulations.
  • Permissible FSI.
  • Potential additional FSI.
  • TDR availability and loading.
  • Premium or other charges, where applicable.
  • Restrictions affecting development.
  • Planning assumptions and calculations.

D. Proposed Redevelopment Options

For each feasible option, the report should explain:

  • Proposed building configuration.
  • Number of floors, subject to applicable approvals.
  • Proposed residential and commercial components.
  • Proposed member rehabilitation area.
  • Common facilities and amenities.
  • Parking provision.
  • Open spaces and recreational areas.
  • Construction specifications.
  • Indicative project layout.

E. Comparative Analysis

Where more than one development option is available, the report should compare the options on a consistent basis.

The comparison should consider:

  • Member entitlement.
  • Additional construction area.
  • Project feasibility.
  • Parking and amenities.
  • Construction and planning constraints.
  • Indicative project costs.
  • Commercial viability.
  • Potential risks and limitations.

F. Assumptions, Qualifications and Limitations

The report should clearly identify:

  • Documents relied upon.
  • Surveys and measurements undertaken.
  • Assumptions used.
  • Approvals and permissions yet to be obtained.
  • Matters requiring independent legal or technical verification.
  • Development benefits that remain subject to approval by the competent authority.

A Project Report is a feasibility and planning document. It should not be represented as a final development permission or a guarantee that every identified development benefit will be sanctioned.

8. Project Report Timeline: Two Months

Paragraph 9 of the 2026 Government Order requires the Architect / PMC to submit the Project Report to the Managing Committee within two months from the date of appointment.

The society should ensure that the appointment agreement expressly incorporates this timeline.

The agreement should also provide for:

  • Defined milestones.
  • Periodic progress updates.
  • Meetings with the Managing Committee.
  • Clarifications and explanations.
  • Submission of draft and final reports, where agreed.
  • Correction of errors or omissions.
  • Delivery of drawings, calculations and supporting documents.

The society should avoid open-ended appointment terms that allow the preparation of the Project Report to remain pending indefinitely.

9. Consideration and Approval of the Project Report

The Architect / PMC’s work does not end with submission of the Project Report.

Paragraph 10 of the 2026 Government Order prescribes the subsequent procedure.

After receiving the report:

  1. The Secretary must convene a Managing Committee Meeting within 30 days.
  2. The Architect / PMC should be invited to attend the meeting.
  3. The Project Report should be made available to members for inspection at the society’s office.
  4. Members should be given an opportunity to submit suggestions and recommendations at least seven days before the committee meeting.
  5. The Secretary should forward the received suggestions to the Architect / PMC for consideration.
  6. The Managing Committee should discuss the suggestions and the professional’s views.
  7. Necessary changes should be considered before the report is approved by majority.
  8. The committee should discuss and prepare the draft tender document.
  9. The draft tender document must thereafter be placed before a Special General Body Meeting for approval.

The society should maintain a record of the Project Report, members’ suggestions, the professional’s responses and the Managing Committee’s decision.

Approval of the Project Report should not be treated as an automatic approval of a particular developer or redevelopment proposal.

It is a technical and planning stage that precedes the tendering and developer-selection process.

10. Architect / PMC’s Role in Preparing Tender Conditions

The Project Report forms the basis for preparing the redevelopment tender.

The Architect / PMC should assist the society in translating the approved redevelopment requirements into clear and measurable tender conditions.

The tender should address matters such as:

  • Minimum carpet area to be provided to existing members.
  • Corpus fund, if proposed.
  • Rent or transit accommodation arrangements.
  • Construction specifications.
  • Quality of materials.
  • Amenities and common facilities.
  • Parking arrangements.
  • Construction timelines.
  • Bank guarantee requirements.
  • Developer’s obligations.
  • Approval and sanction responsibilities.
  • Security and performance obligations.
  • Consequences of delay and breach.
  • Other technical and commercial conditions.

An important provision under Paragraph 10 is that, while preparing the tender draft, the society must keep either carpet area or corpus fund as a fixed, non-variable parameter and determine the other technical terms accordingly.

The tender draft must be placed before a Special General Body Meeting and approved by majority before the tender invitation process proceeds.

The Architect / PMC should therefore ensure that the tender conditions are technically clear, commercially comparable and consistent with the approved Project Report.

11. Role of Architect / PMC in Evaluating Developers’ Offers

The professional’s role may continue during the tendering and developer-selection stages.

The 2026 Government Order provides for scrutiny of received tenders by the Architect / PMC and preparation of a comparative statement.

The professional should examine the offers against the approved tender conditions and identify:

  • Compliance with minimum eligibility conditions.
  • Proposed additional carpet area.
  • Corpus offer, where applicable.
  • Rent and transit accommodation proposals.
  • Construction specifications.
  • Amenities and facilities.
  • Project completion commitments.
  • Financial and technical credentials.
  • Deviations from the tender conditions.
  • Qualifications, exclusions and conditions imposed by the developer.

The comparative statement should present the offers transparently and on a consistent basis.

The society should be cautious about selecting a developer merely because the offer contains the highest additional area or corpus amount.

An attractive commercial offer may contain qualifications, unrealistic assumptions or inadequate financial and technical support.

The Architect / PMC should clearly identify such issues so that members can make an informed decision.

The final selection of the developer remains a decision of the General Body through the procedure prescribed under the Government Order. The Architect / PMC does not have independent authority to select the developer on behalf of the society.

12. Independence and Conflict of Interest

The Architect / PMC is appointed to provide professional assistance to the society. The professional should not function as an undisclosed representative of any prospective developer.

The society should take reasonable steps to ensure independence.

Recommended safeguards include:

  1. Obtain a written declaration of independence.
  2. Require disclosure of any relationship with prospective developers.
  3. Ensure that professional fees are paid by the society under the agreed terms.
  4. Avoid undisclosed commission or referral arrangements.
  5. Require written explanations for material technical recommendations.
  6. Preserve all reports, calculations and communications.
  7. Ensure that the professional does not make commitments on behalf of the society without authority.

The appointment agreement should also specify the circumstances in which the society may terminate the professional’s engagement and the procedure for handing over project records.

13. Common Mistakes Societies Should Avoid

The following mistakes can weaken the redevelopment process:

Mistake 1: Selecting the Cheapest Consultant

A low professional fee does not necessarily indicate competence or value. The society should evaluate experience, technical capability and deliverables.

Mistake 2: Appointing a Consultant Without a Written Agreement

The scope of work, fees, timelines and deliverables should be recorded in a written agreement.

Mistake 3: Accepting an Unsubstantiated FSI Calculation

The development potential must be supported by the applicable regulations and property-specific calculations.

Mistake 4: Ignoring Title and Conveyance Issues

Technical feasibility and legal title are separate aspects. A favourable architectural assessment does not establish that the society has an unencumbered or marketable title.

Mistake 5: Preparing the Project Report Around a Developer’s Offer

The Project Report should objectively examine the property’s potential and the members’ requirements. It should not be tailored to favour a particular developer.

Mistake 6: Not Inviting Members’ Suggestions

The prescribed opportunity for members to submit comments should be implemented properly and documented.

Mistake 7: Treating the Project Report as a Sanctioned Plan

A feasibility report is not a development permission. Actual development remains subject to the requisite approvals and permissions.

Mistake 8: Not Preserving Supporting Documents

The society should retain the report, drawings, calculations, comparative statements, minutes and professional correspondence.

14. Practical Checklist for Housing Societies

Before finalising the Architect / PMC appointment, the Managing Committee should verify the following:

  • Quotations have been obtained from at least three registered Architects / empanelled PMCs, as required.
  • The General Body has selected the professional through the prescribed procedure.
  • Professional qualifications and relevant redevelopment experience have been verified.
  • References and previous project details have been examined.
  • Conflict-of-interest disclosures have been obtained.
  • Scope of work has been clearly defined.
  • Professional fees and payment milestones have been approved.
  • Project Report submission timeline of two months has been incorporated.
  • Survey, FSI/TDR assessment and planning feasibility deliverables have been specified.
  • Different feasible development options will be examined.
  • Member suggestions will be considered in accordance with the Government Order.
  • The society will receive copies of reports, drawings and supporting calculations.
  • A written appointment agreement has been executed.
  • Appointment letter is issued within the prescribed 30-day period.

15. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. Is appointment of an Architect / PMC mandatory in redevelopment?

The 2026 Government Order prescribes the process of obtaining quotations and selecting an Architect / PMC for preparation of the Project Report. The society should follow this procedure before proceeding with the subsequent redevelopment stages.

Q2. How many quotations should the society obtain?

The Government Order requires quotations from at least three registered Architects / empanelled PMCs for preparation of the Project Report.

Q3. Within how many days should the appointment letter be issued?

The appointment letter should be issued within 30 days of the relevant General Body Meeting, in accordance with Paragraph 8 of the Government Order.

Q4. Within what period must the Project Report be submitted?

The Project Report must be submitted to the Managing Committee within two months from the date of appointment of the Architect / PMC.

Q5. Can the Managing Committee independently appoint another consultant without following the prescribed process?

The society should follow the appointment procedure and approvals prescribed by the Government Order. The Managing Committee should not bypass the General Body’s decision or the prescribed quotation process.

Q6. Does the Architect / PMC decide how much additional carpet area members will receive?

No. The Architect / PMC assesses development potential and assists in preparing the Project Report and tender conditions. The members’ entitlements must be determined through the society’s approved redevelopment process and the final contractual arrangements.

Q7. Does the Project Report guarantee that the proposed FSI will be sanctioned?

No. The report is based on the applicable regulations and available information. Final development potential remains subject to verification and approval by the competent planning authority.

Q8. Can the society appoint an advocate separately?

Yes. The Architect / PMC’s technical role does not replace independent legal advice. The society should obtain legal assistance for title verification, conveyance issues, tender vetting, development agreement, Permanent Alternate Accommodation Agreements and other legal documentation.

Q9. Can the Architect / PMC select the developer?

No. The Architect / PMC may scrutinise tenders, prepare comparative statements and provide technical recommendations. The developer must be selected by the General Body through the prescribed process.

Q10. Can the society change its Architect / PMC during the redevelopment process?

The society should examine the appointment agreement, the circumstances requiring replacement and the approvals necessary under the applicable procedure. The change should be properly documented, and all project records should be handed over to the society.

16. Conclusion

The Architect / PMC plays a central role in establishing the technical and commercial foundation of a housing society redevelopment project.

The quality of the Project Report directly affects the society’s ability to formulate realistic tender conditions, evaluate competing developers and protect the interests of its members.

A professional should therefore be selected on the basis of experience, technical competence, independence and accountability rather than merely the lowest quotation.

The Managing Committee should ensure that the appointment is properly documented, the prescribed timelines are followed and members are given a meaningful opportunity to examine and comment on the Project Report.

The next stage is the preparation and approval of the redevelopment tender, which will determine the terms on which developers are invited to submit their proposals.


Related Articles in This 13-Part Redevelopment Guide

  1. Part 1: Housing Society Redevelopment in Maharashtra: The Complete Step-by-Step Roadmap
  2. Part 2: 2019 vs 2026 Government Order: What Has Changed in Maharashtra Housing Society Redevelopment?
  3. Part 3: Before You Begin: Legal, Structural and Financial Checks Before Housing Society Redevelopment
  4. Part 4: Special General Body Meeting for Redevelopment: Notice, Quorum, Voting and Legal Requirements
  5. Part 5: Role of Architect and PMC in Housing Society Redevelopment
  6. Part 6: Tender Process for Housing Society Redevelopment: Rules, Transparency and Developer Offers
  7. Part 7: Developer Selection in Housing Society Redevelopment: Registrar’s Authorised Officer and Voting Procedure
  8. Part 8: Developer Due Diligence: How a Housing Society Should Verify a Redeveloper
  9. Part 9: Development Agreement and PAAA: Protecting Members’ Rights in Redevelopment
  10. Part 10: From Demolition to Possession: Construction, Approvals and Handover
  11. Part 11: Self-Redevelopment and Group Redevelopment in Maharashtra
  12. Part 12: Dissenting, Absent, Deceased and NRI Members in Housing Society Redevelopment
  13. Part 13: Housing Society Redevelopment FAQs, Legal Checklist and Glossary
  14. Download Maharashtra Government GR सगृयो-2026/प्र.क्र.108/14-स for Re-Development dated 30/09/2026

Legal Disclaimer

This article is intended for general legal information and educational purposes. It is based on the Maharashtra Government Order dated 30 September 2026 and should be read with the applicable provisions of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules, 1961, applicable development regulations and subsequent amendments or directions. The development potential of each property depends on its specific title, location, planning authority and applicable regulations. Professional legal and technical advice should be obtained before taking redevelopment decisions.